Sissy Willis posted this morning on Thomas Sowell's Opinion Journal article, "Crippled by Their Culture", on a theme further developed in his book, Black Rednecks and White Liberals
.
Intrigued, I headed to the bookstore only to find out it won't be there until Thursday. Remembering the recommendation from a commenter, The Proprietor of Coffeegrounds, I picked up Born Fighting: How the Scots-Irish Shaped America
by James Webb and How the Scots Invented the Modern World
by Arthur Herman. (They were right next to each other... how could I not?), also quoted by Sisu.
I was immediately hooked by the first paragraph of Born Fighting. Webb describes a drive I made a time or two on the way back to Shreveport from visits to the youngest while she was at William & Mary. It's similar to the routes I travel in my head when I'm working on our family history.
The mountains are beautiful, smoky from the haze that the sun makes when it burns into the pine. My mind plays tricks. I tell myself that I've been right over there, once upon a time, or at least my blood has, taking water straight from a stream and staring out into the wild unknown, dreaming of the majestic deliverance that must be just over the next horizon, hiding in a valley that no white man has ever seen before. Or maybe the next horizon, or the next one, or the next one after that. Which is why my people kept on going, some of them getting hung up, staying behind in the cul-de-sacs of Appalachian hollows while the more adventurous worked their way, ratlike, through the maze until it broke out into Kentucky and then Missouri, Texas, and Colorado, and one day even hit the palm-lined beaches of California.
That's the lure of genealogy for me. I find myself drawn to the stories, imagining as best I can what my ancestor's lives were like, what drove them to pack up and leave land they'd just years before cleared and cultivated to go further west to clear and cultivate more. And... what motivated them to fight?
An example of the Scots-Irish stubbornness and loyalty is Winston County, Alabama and parts of eastern Tennessee during the Civil War.
The people of Winston County, Alabama, hill farmers of modest means, were typical of southern unionists. In 1860, Winston County was the poorest county in Alabama. The per capita value of property was $168 and the county ranked last in cotton production and slaveholding, with only 2 percent of the families owning slaves.
They were largely an isolated mountain people who had little influence on state government. They knew full well that the aristocracy viewed them as socially inferior and saw the impending conflict as “a rich man’s war and a poor man’s fight.”
The leaders of Winston County held a meeting at Looney's Tavern, with attendance in the thousands. There they passed this resolution:
We agree with Jackson that no state can legally get out of the Union; but if we are mistaken in this, and a state can lawfully and legally secede or withdraw, being only a part of the Union, then a county, any county, being a part of the state, by the same process of reasoning, could cease to be a part of the state.
The Looney Tavern group also pled for neutrality, to be left alone by the Confederacy and the Union. They were not. They were branded as traitors and and tories by the Confederacy and persecuted, driving as many as 5,000 Alabamians to serve with various Union regiments, over 2,000 of them in the 1st Alabama Cavalry. Two of these were my great-great-great grandfather, Mordecai M. Cox and his brother-in-law, John Dodd.